Nicotine - Retracted Studies, Papers, and Articles: Difference between revisions

Line 122: Line 122:
==HPHC - Harmful and Potentially Harmful Constituents==
==HPHC - Harmful and Potentially Harmful Constituents==


===2017: [https://pubpeer.com/publications/6E2711F55673ADF831D636E2D701B9 "Juice Monsters": Sub-Ohm Vaping and Toxic Volatile Aldehyde Emissions]===
===2017: RE: [https://pubpeer.com/publications/6E2711F55673ADF831D636E2D701B9 "Juice Monsters": Sub-Ohm Vaping and Toxic Volatile Aldehyde Emissions]===
*Multiple Comments
*Multiple Comments
**"Users will operate the equipment in a way that does not lead to harsh dry puff conditions, with associated high VA formation. This is a key human control feedback that does not exist in laboratory equipment. So experiments that just standardise power settings or volume consumption must take care to validate these are realistic proxies for human use for a particular device. In this paper, many of the coil, power and volume settings combinations were not realistic. That could have been avoided through engaging with people with real practical expertise." (Bates)
**"Users will operate the equipment in a way that does not lead to harsh dry puff conditions, with associated high VA formation. This is a key human control feedback that does not exist in laboratory equipment. So experiments that just standardise power settings or volume consumption must take care to validate these are realistic proxies for human use for a particular device. In this paper, many of the coil, power and volume settings combinations were not realistic. That could have been avoided through engaging with people with real practical expertise." (Bates)